Why is K-pop absent from this year’s Kohaku?

2010 has been a huge year for the success of various K-pop artists, not only in Korea, but in Japan itself.

This year, we’ve seen the largest success rate for K-pop in Japan since the debut of BoA back in 2001, which has caused a renewal of the famed term, “Hallyu/Korean wave”. With BIG BANG, KARA, and Shoujo Jidai/SNSD all shocking fans with their high entries on the Oricon charts, many believed that any one of these groups – or all of them – would be given an invitation to the famous stage at the end of year music special, Kohaku, which occurs on New Year’s Eve.

To some, receiving an invitation to this stage is one of the highlights of a musical career in Japan. Once you receive an invitation, you instantly gain access to a wide variety of audiences, perhaps even gaining a few more fans. Artists such as Angela Aki and Koda Kumi, who have caught their big breaks with one or several hits, have previously gained an invitation to the show are now a staple on the New Year’s special, and both artists are attending once again for 2010.

So why is it that one of the biggest trends in the Japanese music scene this year, and perhaps well into 2011, is absent from the stage?

According to head director of Kohaku, Keisuke Inoue, although it was discussed, an offer simply wasn’t put out.

It is certain that this year, K-pop has been remarkable on the Japanese music scene. This movement will surely continue into next year, and we will support it and see to it, by all means, that it will reach Kohaku’s stage“.

Last year, one of the major surprises on Kohaku was the performance by Susan Boyle, who was the only foreign act.

Inoue also stated the planning of Kohaku was a careful process, where participants were selected and their music was listened to with a certain frame of mind for the show.

Although the official list’s absence of Korean artists came as a surprise to many, there are speculations that KARA and Shoujo Jidai/SNSD might have debuted too late in the year to make it onto the show, despite their success. To add to that point, many Japanese artists work very hard for several years before getting an offer, so the sudden appearance of these groups might have caused a controversy if they had been offered a place on the show “too easily”.

Are you disappointed with the absence of Korean artists on this year’s Kohaku? Let us know your thoughts!

Source: MSN Japan, Special Thanks To Erika


discussion

We welcome your comments, but please be civil, DO NOT SPAM and STAY ON TOPIC. Comments deemed inappropriate will be removed and repeat abusers will be banned. Commenting is a privilege that will be revoked for violations of our Comment Policy.

Comments from our old comments platform are still in the process of moving over. If you notice any comments missing they will likely re-appear soon. Thank you for your patience.

  • paiiro

    i’m not disappoited. (= that’s why i have always adored Jbiz. they chose artists over quality, not quantity.

  • mellody

    [i]To add to that point, many Japanese artists work very hard for several years before getting an offer, so the sudden appearance of these groups might have caused a controversy if they had been offered a place on the show “too easily”.[/i]

    +1. This.
    Premature is Premature~

  • DBSKSNSD4LYFE

    I like SNSD but I don’t feel too bad after having watched DBSK have to wait their turn for a while.

  • maria-chan

    I’m a Kpop fan aswell,but I’m abit pissed off they were so easly invited :/ esp GG.Idk man….I pitty Japanese artists … better for them not to attend,

  • eliteseal

    @#1 I don’t see much quality with this particular year of kohaku with the JE taking over the whole stage.

  • http://www.superyuffie.co.cc Kong Yi Fei

    I’m not disappointed either~ I think it’s too early for them, they did a great success in the oricon chart and they’re getting all the attention from the JPop scene, but I think they should work harder~ ganbatte ^^

  • tumnamen

    I don’t think its that big of a deal right now. these groups just debuted, and and like the article said, even the Japanese artist are around for a number of years before they get on the show, im more surprised that Jero is not on the show.

    I know i personally wish that THSK/JYJ would perform again but i knew that they weren’t going to after all the crap that happened.

    Lets see how these recently debuted kpop acts do in the next few years before we add them to the show.

  • tumnamen

    @DBSKSNSD4LYFE Yes i agree, it took our boys 4 years to get on that show, it wouldn’t be right to add Kara and GG with so little work.

    I don’t even think BoA has ever been on Kohaku, but i could be wrong, and if she can’t get on it that GG gets on in a few months then there is something jacked up

  • kate666

    I’m glad no K-Pop was invited. It’s never been easy for Japanese artists to get invited so why K-Pops ?

    Japanese groups that have sold so much more still don’t make it… you can list many. For example, KAT-TUN and NEWS with 100% of their singles went to No.1 on Oricon haven’t been invited yet , then why inviting others that still haven’t made it THAT BIG in Japan.

  • lee_na204

    I love SNSD but i dont really think they deserve to go to Kohaku. Maybe if SNSD/KARA keep up the sucess then they can get an invite,besides its not like the end of the world if they dont get invited lol.

  • ShoJu

    I’m sorry but Susan Boyle was NOT the only foreign artist at last years Kohaku as Tohoshinki where also there that year (for the second time).
    With that said, it doesn’t come as a surprise that Kpop is absent this year as there hasn’t been much focus on the japanese market for Kpop-artists until the end of the year and as such none were invited.

  • silencio88

    I think everyone has said it already: it’s too early for Big Bang, SNSD and Kara to stand on that stage. They have to prove that they have staying power. A few singles topping the weekly Oricon just doesn’t cut it yet.

    @eliteseal I don’t have complaints with SMAP, TOKIO and Arashi. The first two groups have performed for more than 15 times in Kohaku already. As for Arashi, they’ve accomplished a lot especially in the last 2 years. I’m iffy about NYC being there, though. I think it should have been V6 instead.

  • Orihime

    I’m not disappointed I’m happy they’re not coming. Maybe their hardcore fans are disappointed but honestly majority of the artists that got invited worked 5-10 yrs already, these kpop groups can’t compare so honestly it’s toooo~ soon~~~~~
    -
    Beside Japanese always invited the sempai artists out of respect anyway.

  • KurenaiHime

    @tumnamen Actually BoA’s already been on Kohaku 5 times lol.

  • sasori

    IT’S BECAUSE THEY SUCK DOH.

  • sergel02

    @8 With the groups you mentioned its mainly because Johnny Entertainment will only send 2 acts, because that’s all Kohaku will allow.
    and i’ll just say what i said on AKP
    I think they all need to leave a bigger impact in Japan. Look at Kana Nishino for example. This is her first time, but from what i know, she didn’t have the support like those 3 groups had when they debuted in Japan, she really had to work her way up. Since she debuted in February 2008, she’s released 2 albums and 13 singles. Not saying Kara, SNSD, and Big Bang aren’t hard-working, but i think they need to leave a bigger impact before getting something so prestigious.

  • Carryon

    seriously, I LOVE k-pop!! … but i love J-pop so much more. ^^’ and i serously think k-pop belongs to Korea, and j-pop belongs to Japan. I mean, it’s great that there’s kpop in japan and the otherway around too…. but there’s almost MORE kpop than jpop in Japan, and i just think (my personal oppinion ^^’)that’s wrong…

  • MonAmi

    Agreed with everyone else, not disappointed.

  • http://www.noneofyobusiness.com marmar

    I’m not disappointed. I’m a big KARA fan & as much as I would love to see them gain alot of success in Japan being invited to Kohaku is just WAY too early. So it’s better this way. Let them really gain their footing in Japan. Let them make a name for themselves instead of depending on their popularity from KARA. Really become a big Japanese artist. I know they can do it :)

  • Arashi_Kat-tun

    I’m definitely NOT disappointed one bit! I mean like seriously! it’s been how long since DBSK has been around and their last year together was their first time on Kohaku! and Arashi?! it’s their second time! they’ve been around since 1999!!!!!!!!! and plus, Koreans should stay on their own turf for new year’s eve…..i don’t want my mom to turn off the tv because they appear :(

  • YukiNozofan

    I agree with everyone else x)

  • faifantc

    I’m not disappointed. The only Korean artist who I think deserves to be on Kohaku is BoA because she’s been around in the Japanese scene for a while, but I don’t think that a lot of artists who are appearing in Kohaku should be. NYC for example. It’s unfair that they get to appear their first and second years. It’s not okay. Arashi had to wait ten years, and V6, NEWS, and K8 deserve to appear way before those boys. I’m not upset that K-pop is staying in Korea for New Year’s Eve because they should. First and foremost, it is a Japanese music show.

  • shiroyamacah

    shiroyamacah
    i like the new group. Love 4minute’s debut and SNSD’s one too. But like was said, many artists work hard to be here. Tohoshinki appeared in 2009, true. but they took time for that. and more that i like kpop, jpop will not allow newbies in their market to appears in such special place, like kpop would do in their country. probsbly will take 1 year or 2, depending how much improviment the groups will have *specially with learning the japanese language*

  • shiroyamacah

    besides, even BoA need to be in kohaku too, during Tohoshinki just was there last year! *and hope in the future to all 5 be together and go there again XD*. Japanese industry is just protecting their artists, like many countries do…..

  • kwsmaria

    no one cares that kpop is not attending kohaku. This article shouldn’t be written in the first place.
    They don’t deserve to attend. They are not fluent in Japanese. SNSD released two singles that were re-released.

  • Forsythia

    In fact I’m relieved. They do not deserve to be invited to Kohaku as of now yet,give them more time to polish their music and adapt to the Japanese music industry. I love all 3 groups,but they’re not being dedicated enough to jpop. GD and TOP barely rap in Japanese,too much English in their songs to cover up for their lack of proficiency in the language,SNSD and KARA should also polish their Japanese and release more original Japanese songs.

  • kawun

    Not disappointed at all. Pretty glad they aren’t coming too :). I would be extremely mad if they attended. They do not deserve to be on a show like Kohaku. It is a highly prestigious event in Japan. Maybe in 4 years if they work hard enough :). The Japanese get tired of Korean artists really quickly. Unless you had that amount of dedication BoA and DBSK had.
    Thank you Kohaku representatives.
    Btw, why is there even an article written about this… No one wants such K-Pop artists to be at Kohaku anyways.

  • Kuon

    I can honestly say I am relieved that none were invited. As the article stated that: sudden appearance of these groups might have caused a controversy if they had been offered a place on the show “too easily”.

    I also agree with #1 over quality not quantity. J-artists work much harder to make it on the show than anyone else.

  • sugarbunni

    As big a fan I am of all those groups, it would not have been a good idea to invite them. It would just look like they were invited because they are a novelty, not actual talent. They are talented singers, but to invite them so soon would reflect badly on Kohaku and K-pop artists.
    P.S. Don’t say that those groups suck. They are definitely talented, but they’re just not ready for Kohaku yet.

  • http://ipandaxpnai ipandaxpnai

    Am I disappointed? HELL TO THE NO. JPop artists have worked hard to get to the point where they are today and it would be completely unfair if a bunch of kpop artists stole the show from them. & to be honest, jpop songs have actual feelings put into them whereas kpop is just about the beat and making sure that the lyrics are addicting. -_-;

  • arashi_oneday

    Not disappointed at all and quite glad indeed. I love all 3 groups but inviting them would just be unfair and ridiculous.

  • D_YaNa

    I’m agree to all of you~~ The thought of having k-pop group in kohaku not once ever cross in my mind.. I’m a fan of k-pop too, but I’m so shock that some people expecting them to be in kohaku~ ==”
    And I think the reason for having NYC is just a condition for having Arashi, like you all hv already know that NHK only allow two JE idol~~
    BUT why not KATTUN/NEWS/V6? hhhmmmmm.. let see, KATTUN/NEWS/V6 still can work past midnight, so maybe JE think it is better if they just stay on countdown, and just let this NYC underage kids that only can work before midnight work on kohaku ~? BUT WHY in earth NYC instead of HEY!SAY!JUMP~? FYI JOHNNY-san/MARY/JULIE I HATE THAT NAKAsomething-GUY !! Why must he be on kohaku, why can’t we just put Hey!Say!Jump for god sake, my YUTO~? I thought you are a smart ass, Johnny~~!
    eeehhhh.. chotto~ I think I just get it, NYC have a smaller no. of member compare to hey say jump, so having NYC instead of Hey Say Jump = more money for jimusho ,ne ~! Yha.. after all you are a smart ass,ne Johnny-san~~
    Mhaaaa~~ sorry for talking all this crap, this just my theory for all this NYC thingy~~ ^^v

  • Kuon

    @32: This is Johnny we’re talking about xD he can do whatever he wants (plus he redefined boy bands, something we should all be happy about).

  • YoshiFail

    Honestly I am happy to the bones. These artists here deserve to be on this show, they worked really hard for their fans.

  • atarashi26michi

    to be honest, im rele glad that kpop isnt in kohaku this year
    kpop is invading into the j-entertainment scene
    and it rele worries me that artists who have been working for years to be able to earn the honor would get replaced by kpop artists who have debuted in japan for a few months
    kpop artists like kara and SNSD are good, but there are many more outstanding artists in japan who may not rank as high and are being blocked out
    i want them to have their chance
    DBSK had to wait for their chance
    if choshinsei hasnt made it to kohaku yet, then i dont want the newer kpop turned jpop groups to be here
    i just feels wrong.
    like this is AAA’s first time on kohaku
    it would be wrong if a kpop group got on when this is AAA’s first time after they’ve debuted for like 5 years ad have always been popular.
    so im not disappointed.

  • SNSDism

    It’s good enough that they’re even being considered. :D But it doesn’t matter, I’d rather have them in Korea than in Japan for the New Years.

    @Arashi_Kat-tun: That doesn’t sound racist or anything.

  • –JongKey–

    No, i’m not disappointed. And no, i don’t know anything about J-pop, i’m just starting to get into it but even i know how prestigious Kohaku is and you think that people who have only been on the scene for a couple of months are going to get on it? Other people have worked so hard and they have spent many years trying and then now they have finally have a chance and newly K-pop groups should just be able to get onto it that fast? No way, lol. They need to prove that they deserve it.
    ——-
    I’m pretty sure in a couple of years they will be invited, we’ll just sit back and watch how their fame grows and when they truly deserve it, they WILL be on Kohaku =DD Wow, essay much? Lol

  • 365musiclover

    I’m Sad but i understand what everyones saying
    So i cant wait till NEXT YEAR!!!!
    SNSD FIGHTING <3

  • kawun

    @SNSDism
    LOL, you really think they actually ‘considered’ it? How else could they have delt with all the delusional K-Pop fans if they didn’t put out some nice words? :)

  • NEWSmomosu

    He shouldn’t have had to sugar coat it for the kpop fans. That was too nice of him. =/

  • atarashi26michi

    @SNSDism
    of course its not racist.
    how can it be racist if they’re of the same race (asian)?
    i mean rele, choose your words better.

  • Bluebird

    Why are people making a big deal about K-pop artists not being invited to this event? They are still rookies in Japan.

  • Aki29

    I dont want Kpop artists appear on Japanese traditional music event, especially they have just debuted for a year or months, its so unfair and ridiculous if they are invited in Kohaku while many other artists must work very hard to have this chance ( of course, some super star like Susan Boyle are exception :D )

  • charait

    The Kohaku producers made a good choice by not inviting Kpop artists in this case. There would be a lot of conflict for them and I prefer seeing them in Korea’s end of the year shows. It’s a huge honor to even be considered, of course, so SNSD, KARA and Big Bang are probably happy enough with that.

  • Kuon

    @42: They must think that their idols should get everything handed to them on a gold platter. Few months = Ultimate success

  • tonbi

    this doesn’t come as a surprise to me at all. kohaku is the most traditional japanese music program there is, and its extremely rare to find any foreign artists making an appearance on it. even DBSK took years before they got to be on the show.

  • 29 Blue Roses

    LOL~ no~ I’m not disappointed at all~ If Kohaku let these three groups to be on the show then it would not be Kohaku anymore right? I meant, Kohaku will lose its value, of course.

  • Cupcakemastermind

    brats, all of you

  • dark_halo

    I am not disappointed too. There are many great artists out there in Japanese music industry that should perform in Kohaku. I am sad that some of them are not given a chance in performinh on Kohaku :(

  • dark_halo

    There are many great Jmusicians out there who hasn’t been given a chance to perform on Kohaku and I am so sad. More Jmusicians please :)

  • dark_halo

    I am not disappointed too. There are many great J-musicians that should perform on Kohaku. They should be given an exposure.

  • rainmocoharuma

    I`m not disappointed , satisfied with Japanese artists

  • seto89

    Kpop songs are mostly catchy and trendy (with hot guys & girls of course) but not beautifully written. that’s gonna cost them some points. they don’t have the songs to cry for.

    come on..kohaku is a really boring event. why do you guys even care? (to kpop fanatic fans)

    and susan boyle, well, her songs are good enough, i think. and her voice is nice too. so, why not??

  • http://youtube.com/user/wvrtv Neika

    I think the J artists that aren’t getting a lot of exposure should get the exposure before giving that opportunity to k artists, after that is satisfied then k artists can get a shot…

  • koorisora

    Kouhaku should stay the same as it is..

  • Lenna-Rena

    I don’t like it when there are new korean bands on kouhaku.
    DBSK was great, i was their biggest fan.
    kouhaku is a great japanese tradition to watch it every year. nearly every single family in japan watches it. We only want people who are close, at least in nationality.
    damn. stuff i say doesnt make sense. i just want to say that Kouhaku is JAPANESE, i don’t like new koreans on it who think it’s obvious and normal to get on the show. it’s not. it’s even the greatest thing for japanese people who have amazing talent and try extremely hard.

  • Tsumugi

    OMG! Let scandal to be on there first before k-artists. I am so glad that AAA is able to attend kohaku after so much hard work.

  • shiroyamacah

    @lenna-rena
    “i was their biggest fan” u are not more? O.o

    *sorry, just need to ask it ^^”

  • PupPupPop

    Wait, most of the people here are saying the K-POP groups haven’t worked ‘hard enough’ to go on Kohaku. But that’s not true, they have worked hard just not in Japan. They first came out in 2007 and worked hard for 3 years to get to Japan. Susan Boyle also had to work hard for years to get that voice she has. Yes, and I would love to see other Japanese artist like SCANDAL in Kohaku. But do all of you have to say they don’t deserve to be on there all because they are Korean?

  • xsayax

    I’m not disappointed. I’m actually kind of glad, I would actually be really shocked if they had made it onto Kohaku since they haven’t been around in Japan that long. I really love SNSD and KARA, but they need to work at it for a few more years in Japan and secure their fanbase. After all, lots of the popular K-POP groups just debuted a few months ago.

  • kashiko

    @59: not really. We just said these K-pop groups just debut a few months ago andit would be unfair if they are invited.

  • firefye

    @ 59 Yes, they have worked hard in Korea and they’ve achieve success there. It’s unrealistic to think KPOP groups should have the same level of success in Japan for their work else where (don’t get me started on Susan Boyle, you all know things roll differently if you are successful in America).
    If a group wants to break into JPOP they will start from scratch – SNSD, KARA and Big Bang all knew they’d be back to being rookies.

  • xTaeGang Unitex

    it took some of j-pops biggest acts many years of hit singles to be invited. Now there are new groups who have been in japan for a few months and they’re invited?! -.-’ that is not right.
    And secondly, STOP BRINGING ALL THESE GROUPS INTO KOREA! When BoA and THSK came over, it was fine. Big Bang came over, okay… and now there are like 5 more kpop groups that are going/in jpop right now. -.-”

  • lilitu

    there’s no need to even explain why those groups are not Kohaku. >.> just saying. i’m satisfied with Kohaku’s line up … only would change one or two outta that list but not for any Kpop newbie.

  • bellelynx

    If it’s DBSK that we’re talking about here then Kpop artist’s absence is a question..but if it’s not,then this thing shouldn’t be an issue …

    there are far more deserving Jpop/Jrock groups who didn’t make it to Kohaku this year and they didn’t even make a big deal out of it.

  • kitmiaoww

    Not surprised? To me Kohaku marks an artists true success in Japan. Having climbed and worked hard to the day they deserve to be on Kohaku. Sorry but I don’t think any of the kpop artists “speculated” to appear on Kohaku have proven themselves Kohaku material. Yet. And perhaps never unless they either become INTERNATIONAL stars or go through the hard route same way BoA and THSK did.

  • Tsumugi

    @59: We are not saying that kpop artists are not working hard. But there are jpop artists like AAA,Scandal,Dream and so many who have been working as hard and good as those kpop artists and debuted long in their own country, Japan? So aren’t they should be the one who are invited first before kpop artists? If those kpop artists who just debuted in japan for a few months and get to be in kohaku, the show on which most j-artists dream to be, it would be so unfair for those j-artists. No matter how you see, it is so unfair for them.

  • Tsumugi

    @59: for Susan Boyle case, it is different. She attended kohaku as foreign artist so not affect jpop artists from attending Kohaku. For kpop groups, they will be in white and red teams since they are considered as foreign artists debuting in Japan and singing in Japanese, being hindrance from attending to those underrated but working-hard jpop artists. If they have debuted long enough like TVXQ and BoA, nobody will complain about it.

  • matsujunforever

    OF COURSE NOT!! this is the best kohaku eveerrrrrr!!! horray J-MUSIC!!! .. can it be every year there is no Kpop? wooh!!

  • arastal

    I’m not disappointed but rather satisfied.

    Kouhaku is a stage where all J artistes aim for as it is a stage where you know you are very successful. By having new kpop groups such as snsd and kara entering, they are bringing down the standard and expectations of the stage. I am not saying that they are not good etc but they have to understand that it takes time and effort for other artistes to work their way up.

    As a tvxq fan, when kouhaku finally let these five boys perform on the stage, we fans were really proud of them as they done very well and earn themselves glory.

    No kpop in it, i am rather thankful. it is also another reason why i watch it (:

  • happy7

    Im not disappointed too, coz KPOP like KARA & SNSD to junior to join Kokuhaku. Altot they was great succes in japan but still junior. Only selected performence can get it. let it be special.

  • happy7

    too much KPOP this year in JPOP, im afraid its gonna influence Jpop culture. & soon ppl gonna sick about KPOP.

  • viyage

    umm..i’m sorry? y should I be disappointed??

    i mean..nothing personal really… i do love kpop but I’d rather see jpop artists on this stage more than kpop

    to be honest..I don’t want any kpop who just debuted in Japan for like what a year?? and they attend Kohaku?? I mean COME ON? even a Japanese artist themselves must do a very fine work to attend this concert!!

    for Tohoshinki im telling u guys that its totally acceptable for me…they were big in Japan..like really and THEY HAV BEEN DEBUTED FOR LIKE 4 or 5 YEARS…not just a year!

    so yeah…I’ll just say i’m not disappointed or well…i’m actually happy about that!

  • monkeyshinobi

    K-pop does have meaningful songs. You just need to look for them.

  • monkeyshinobi

    More clashing between k-pop and j-pop fans =___= But it’s good they weren’t invited because it isn’t fair to the artists that take a long time to gain popularity and recognition.

  • aki_suki01

    This is a good thing because it’s not fair to hard working Japanese musicians who work extremely hard and yet don’t get an invitation. If some Korean groups were to be invited onto the show, it would have been total disrespect for Japanese musicians who couldn’t get on the show to be outdone by newbies from a foreign country who had only newly arrived with not much experience in the Japanese market. I would rather have these hard working Japanese musicians on than the newly debuted Korean groups flooding Japan.

  • aki_suki01

    you mean Japan. I got you but yeah, need to stop bringing all these korean groups into Japan and flooding it.

  • aki_suki01

    you mean Japan. I got you but yeah, need to stop bringing all these korean groups into Japan and flooding it.

  • http://twitter.com/imadogarfarf Karen Conde

    actually even if I love KPOP I was happy that no one attended 2010’s Kohaku… because there are more deserving JPOP groups who should attend this event.. as for TVXQ I’m happy for them because their hard works have paid off, but still even if I love that group I still do think that Kohaku should invite JPOP artists before a foreign artist first because it would be unfair for those JPOP or Jrock bands who have been working hard for so long but still didn’t even get the chance to be in that event.